❊ What a Year! Top 11 Non-Political Lebanese Blog Stories of 2011

The year 2011 started with a bang. Literally. The very first post in Beirut Spring in 2011 was about the new year eve’s explosion in Alexandria Egypt. At the time we didn’t realize it, but that explosion set the tone for a year that turned out to be explosive and tumultuous in many ways.

The Arab spring and the turmoil in Lebanese politics dominated the 1,210 posts in this blog in 2011. But this year also witnessed other stories and off-beat, quirky little Lebanese memes that helped shape the year in their own way.

In this end-of-year post, you will find a recollection of these stories and hopefully you’ll remember the debates, laughs and anger they generated. This is a subjective list. It speaks more to this blogger’s interests than to the general Lebanese Zeitgeist. That said, I hope you all find it useful, delightful and worth sharing.

Without further Ado, I present you the list and wish a happy new year to you all!


Ontornet

Last year, we started noticing a problem: Lebanon had one of the worst internet connections in the world. But in 2011, it went even more downhill and became the absolute worse. It dawned on us that our government was woefully ill equipped to deal with the matter and that Lebanon is getting behind in many cool technologies. The internet was so slow that I found it very difficult to blog when I visited Lebanon.

The online (and offline) activists began taking matters in their own hands. Movements like Ontornet and Flip the Switch were born and the Lebanese stakeholders started having conversations about the internet in Lebanon. The world noticed, and international media started writing about Lebanon’s “painfully slow” internet connection.

The loud complaining and constant activism started paying off, as the Lebanese gradually began getting a more decent connection. But many remain unconvinced, as the faster connection that was announced with much pomp and fanfare took ages to improve and many hurdles came along the way.


How the world sees Lebanon, and how we see ourselves

As the summer of 2011 approached, many of us started noticing that there’s an unusual amount of foreign articles and TV reports on why “Beirut is Back”. So much so in fact that Angie wrote a post to serve as a template to save them time and trouble. We then realized that all these infomercials somehow included references to specific fancy new Beirut hotels and we made a connection.

We enjoyed talking about how international celebrities and comedians saw Lebanon, how foreign bloggers analyzed our habitsWe got angry when we noticed that they’re giving too much importance to things like the Beirut nightlife, or that some of them didn’t like our country, or when writers fell too deep into stereotyping.

But then we turned our gaze inward, into how Lebanon promoted itself to the outside world. We discovered an old Lebanese tradition of promoting Lebanon using scantly clad women, a tradition that survived very well. We discussed tv ads that were made to promote our little piece of heaven. We talked about how women are used to sell our country, about beauty pageants and plastic surgery. We then naturally sidetracked into talking about the state of advertising in Lebanon and about the lovable (and not so lovable) characters Lebanese ads spawned.


Racism and the abuse of foreign workers

The Lebanese awareness of the abuse of foreign domestic workers started in 2010. But 2011 was the year in which the issue really took off. Things got so bad we started having billboards telling us to treat workers well. The Philippines started arresting people who wanted to work in Lebanon. There were even studies on the sexuality of maids in Lebanon and how they are treated by their madames. Generally, the matter started garnering significant international exposure and became a real embarrassment.

The Lebanese fought back against such abuses. Activists wrote songs condemning their treatment and the government began implementing some imperfect programs to protect the worker’s rights. Still, the matter of racism in Lebanon remains far from solved, as it lingers on in parts of the media and some municipalities.


The “revolution against sectarianism”

I was hesitating to include this story in the list because it could be thought of as a political story. But I made an exception because of the amount of energy that was spent debating the issue on this blog.

At the height of the Arab spring, a group of Lebanese men and women decided that Lebanon’s revolution will be against the sectarian order ruling the country. It was an admirable and catchy idea, and indeed the demonstrations kept getting bigger and bigger. But I always got the feeling that something was wrong with their approach, and I kept writing post after post to elaborate my ideas. It is no use rehashing the arguments I and many other people made (if you’re really interested, you can click on the links), but the movement ended up divided and conquered by the very forces it was railing against, and eventually it fizzled away.

The protest movement itself, (which should not be confused with the Laicité movement)  went away, but its ideas greatly influenced the political conversation in the country.


Guinness world records and voting for Jeita

I didn’t invent the term “international celebrity syndrome”, but it adequately describes an almost pathological Lebanese need for recognition in the world. This manifested itself in a relentless drive to collect Guinness world records for bizarre and questionable achievements.

But the biggest manifestation of this was in the “vote for Jeita” frenzy that gripped Lebanon for several weeks. So much campaigning took place and so much public money was spent that the online activists took part of a backlash.

Bloggers resented the relentless pressure to vote. Some said the competition was a scam and that the campaign to promote voting was a ripoff. Some wondered about the misplaced set of politicians’ priorities.

In the end Jeita lost, and this helped many to become more accepting of the arguments against the competition.


Social media hits the Lebanese mainstream

One reason why the Lebanese were so upset with the slow internet is because it was interfering with their new habit of enjoying Facebook, Twitter and other online social networks. Twitter proved to be surprisingly popular in Lebanon, but Facebook had its fans too. Actually Facebook was so popular that it had to be banned from parliament because it was distracting our dear MPs.

People began suing each other because of Facebook content. The Prime Minister expressed his wish to create a “hi-tech ministry”. Officials started learning about bloggers and decided to regulate their work, which created a storm online that caused them to backtrack.

But the Lebanese really took note when politicians started using Twitter. After a long public absence, Ex Prime Minister and opposition leader Saad Hariri chose Twitter to be his medium to talk to the Lebanese. This created a stampede of mainstream journalists jumping on the Twitter bandwagon, despite the challenges some of them had understanding the medium.

To welcome Twitter newcomers, I published a guide of suggested Lebanese people to follow that many of you found very useful.


Censorship

For some reason, 2011 was a year where a lot of censorship happened in Lebanon. There was self censorship in websites that belong to both sides of the Lebanese political divide. There was a prestigious international photojournalism exhibit that was cancelled, a Lebanese singer was jailed because of a song about the president. Iranian movies, Lebanese movies, even posters of movies were censored.

The censorship sometimes was so flagrant and bizzarre that the Lebanese fought back and won. It lead to research about how censorship in Lebanon works and who really is to blame. But this remains an uphill battle, as censorship remains acceptable in many Lebanese quarters.


Women’s rights

Thanks to heroic efforts by activists, the issue of women rights took center stage in the Lebanese consciousness in 2011. We learned that women in Lebanon face two main challenges: A legal system that treats them like second class citizens, and a society that views them as sexual objects. The prevalence of rape and harassment was the consequence of such an environment.

Some of the advocacy paid off and the lady activists started getting recognition and real returns on their efforts. One Lebanese party even elected a woman as its leader. But the arrival of the all-male Mikati cabinet came as a huge symbolic setback for the ladies’ cause and portended legislation that is grossly unfair to the Lebanese fair sex.


The fight against smoking

There had been some grumblings about the prevalence of smoking in public places in Lebanon, but serious things began happening in 2011. The Lebanese Broadcasting Corporation (LBC) banned smoking on its premises and said it will stop accepting cigarette ads. The parliament started debating an anti smoking law and a public discussion that involved all stake holders was launched.

Some independent initiatives tested the waters, and in the end we got a good law. But many wondered if it’s possible to enforce in a place like Lebanon.


Protecting Beirut’s heritage

2011 had a fair amount of rumors and warnings of historical and cultural buildings that were about to be taken down to be replaced by commercial establishments. We agonized over the fate of the Glass café in Gemmayze, we discussed the fate of the Egg-shaped building and questioned the frenzy over the shutting down of Theatre de Beyrouth. We had great discussions about effective online advocacy for heritage conservation.


Bonus little memes

The evil valet parking dudes:

Because parking in Beirut is so stressful and because of TV reports that the valet parking guys are spying on us, it was inevitable that the Valet-Parking people became so reviled across the blogosphere in 2011.

Websites that were hacked:

Many websites were hacked in 2011. Hezbollah hacked the Future Movement‘s sites, The Saudis hacked Wi2am Wahhab’s site, The Syrians hacked the website of the Beirut Bar association and the homepage of Harvard University, Some Syrian regime websites were hacked and we learned that the notorious Anonymous community of hackers has set its eyes on Assad .

Even yours truly wasn’t spared.

Apps, Ecommerce and New Looks:

As smartphones became more common, we started learning about Lebanese apps that are fun, quirky and successful. Lebanon’s mainstream media got into the apps business , and so did some Arab revolutions. Blog posts about iPhone advice became common and people started caring about Steve Jobs.

After some initial complaining, Lebanon started getting decent E-Commerce sites.

News websites redesigned their online presence: The Daily Star, Naharnet and Annahar all sported new looks. Annahar even gave a facelift to its actual newspaper and Al-Akhbar introduced an English edition.

Languages:

In 2011, I implored the Lebanese to face the fact that the French language in Lebanon is dying. I also looked at the coming of age of Arabic , the real one and the online variety. I also shared why I chose English to be the language in which I blog

❊ In Lebanon, The “Superficial Glitter” of Christmas is Precisely the Cause for Celebration

Today in his Christmas sermon, Pope Benedict XVI asked the Catholic flock to turn away from the “superficial glitter” of Christmas and return to the simple religious roots of this occasion. A few days before, a wacko who calls himself an Islamic scholar said that “Saying Merry Christmas is worse than killing someone”.

Of course I don’t want to create an analogy between the two. The Pope is one of the world’s most revered people and the bearded guy is an ignorant and obscure extremist. But in a world where the Christians listen to the pope and the Muslims listen to that “scholar”, this would never happen:

Lebanese veiled woman wearing Santa-Claus costume

This is a picture from Saida of a veiled Muslim woman wearing a Santa Claus costume. I found her to be the perfect mascot for a Lebanon in which Muslims are increasingly celebrating Christmas by decorating trees in their homes and taking part of festivities. Some like Minister Ghazi Aridi, a druz, even set up big nativity scenes in their homes.

Both the pope and the wacko scholar would frown at this picture. The Santa Claus red costume is part of the commercialization and glitter that the pope dislikes. A veiled woman wearing it is an appostate to Islamists.

And yet in Lebanon it’s happening and it’s great news. Because in Lebanon, the superficial glitter is precisely the part of Christmas that unifies the people and creates peace and love between Christians and their neighbors. Isn’t that what Christianity is supposed to be all about?

Merry Christmas to all of you my dear readers, and I hope you have a great new year.

What are Charbel Nahhas and Fadi Abboud Doing in the Same Political Party?

Charbel Nahhas & Fadi Abboud

One is rumored to be a closet communist and the other is a capitalist industrialist par excellence. Yet they are both tagging along in the same political party.

The spat between ministers Charbel Nahhas and Fadi Abboud over the minimum wage hike is not the kind of minor disagreements colleagues regularly have. This is a fundamental ideological difference that typically causes people in democracies to join opposite parties, parties that will never agree on economic issues and who leave it to the voters to decide which direction they prefer.

The FPM, like other Lebanese parties is built around people, not economic issues. But even by Lebanese standards the combination of Nahhas and Abboud is odd. You won’t find a leftist economist big-wig in the Future Movement and you won’t find a Milton Friedman becoming a minister at the Progressive Socialist Party. Parties left and right do join coalitions, but on economic issues Lebanese parties are internally harmonious.

I took a look at the FPM Charter and found this paragraph:

10. [The FPM aspires to] adhere to the free economic system and personal initiative within the boundaries of human dignity and the welfare and principles of social justice.

This “aspiration” is loaded with keywords that are designed to please both the left and the right, but it doesn’t actually mean anything. The FPM is not even a centrist party, as Nahhas’ extreme minimum wage proposal illustrated yesterday. This is an ideologically multipolar beast designed around people and narrow interests.

Not Rushing to Call This One

A big part of me is convinced that Syrian regime is behind the dual explosions that took place today in Damascus and killed dozens of people. About an hour ago I tweeted the following:
Let’s see if the Syrian regime can pull off a more convincing ‘Abu 3adas’ video this time..

The Syrian regime has a remarkable ability of conjuring up terrorist ‘Alqaeda’ activity whenever it’s convenient to it. It can’t be a coincidence that the explosions took place at the same day the Arab league’s observers came to Syria to monitor the regime’s excesses. Moreover, the area in question is heavily secured and it’s difficult to imagine an armed outsider slipping in with a bomb. Last but not least, the immediacy with which the regime announced that this was a suicide attack by Alqaeda and started streaming endless graphic images on TV appears suspiciously rehearsed.

But is this conviction beyond any reasonable doubt?

There are people out there who believe that the Syrian opposition is entirely peaceful. They dream of a Ghandian resistance that will overthrow the thugs of the Assad regime with the sole power of their will and conviction. I’m not one of those people.

That doesn’t mean that I’m subscribed to the Assad version of events. I don’t for instance believe that the revolutionary were armed “gangs and terrorists” from the beginning. But I do believe that there are many people out there who lost brothers, sisters, children and mothers to that regime and have sworn to themselves that they’ll get even. Considering the amount of regional enemies the regime has, I also believe that the revolutionaries have easy access to bomb-making materials and expertise. So it is not a wild stretch of the imagination to believe that the explosions were a form of “payback” to a bloody regime by people who lost loved ones.

This is why I’m holding judgment for the moment. We could very well be witnessing a new bloody chapter in this Syrian civil war..

Lebanon’s Extreme Minimum Wage Proposal

There are some, like me, who oppose the minimum wage on principle. But there are others who support the idea but who find the proposal to hike the minimum wage to 560$ pretty extreme.

Ghassan Karam is such an economist, and after doing some back-of-the-envelop calculations he concluded:

the Lebanese proposal would make the Lebanese minimum wage [..] the highest such wage rate in the world. Actually had it not been for Argentina, Venezuela and Turkey the Lebanese rate could easily be judged to be twice the global average for countries at its level of GDP per capita

This is insane. The FPM has decided to make this about politics instead of sound economics. It is an act of irresponsible populism that the FPM members themselves know is not good for the economy. This is an in-your-face buying of votes at the expense of growth and employment.

Messrs. Mikati and Safadi should fight this tooth-and-nail and use politics if they had to. They should threaten to resign rather than approve such an abomination.

Also: Why the minimum wage is a bad idea.

❊ The Real Surprise is that Theatre de Beyrouth is Still Around

Theatre de Beyrouth

- Into the sunset -

So apparently the Beirut Theater with a glorious past will be put out of its misery and shut down [update: No it won't]. It is about time.

Activists are trying to stop this from happening. They are trying to blame things like “capitalism” and “greed”. They are charging against the “toothless” ministry of culture for not “stepping in” to save this Beirut institution from an ignominious fate that befell many other august cultural establishments. They are waxing poetics on the “pricelessness” of theatre and its value to our society ..

But they’re missing the point. The place is shutting down simply because people are not going anymore. People are no longer paying to watch theater like they used to, especially not in an area now with perpetual traffic where you cannot even park a car. Theatre de Beyrouth had its glory days, but now things are no longer the same. Such is life: Times change. Great people die and so do great institutions. Get over it.

But I’ll ignore this for a while and ask: What is your solution to the problem? Should the minister of culture step in and start pouring in tax-payer money to keep alive a place nobody wants to go to anymore? From where should he take that money? From government’s free education budget or from government provided health insurance? Besides, this is a privately owned business and the owner can do whatever he wishes with it. Are you now recommending that the government take people’s property away from them?

But what about Lebanese theater as an art form? Should we just allow it to die?

This is a problem for Lebanese theater lovers to solve, not for the owner of one particular establishment. Fans and performers can set up shop in any place they wish. Bohemian culture thrives in meat-packing districts, public parks and abandoned warehouses, not in a tiny space with one of Lebanon’s highest real-estate rates.

So are we just going to throw away years of  history that spanned the life of Theatre de Beyrouth?

Of course not. We have books and museums precisely to document such things. You can even create an online mazar for the place, filled with photos, walk throughs, videos of performances, music soundtracks and scans of original scripts.

Theatre de Beyrouth belongs in a warm spot in our memories, but not in our future..

Update: Apparently it won’t be shut down after all..

Also: What should we do about the Beirut egg?
And: Ahwet el 2zez is shutting down for a good reason.