Labor Minister Butros Harb has authored a draft law that would prevent Christians and Muslims from selling property to each other for a period of 15 years, in order to “safeguard national coexistence.” In the draft legislation, Harb cited fears that the demographic balance in Lebanon would be affected by a recent, “quasi-organized” trend in land sales from members of one religion to another.
This law is an insult to each and every one of us. It lays bare the state of bankruptcy that our sectarian democracy has reached. I understand the uneasiness some Christians are feeling, but the solution is not in passing a law that prevents the sale of lands from Christians to Muslims. This is the part where we look in the mirror and realize what a farce our country has become.
We have separate civil laws for Muslims and Christians. We prevent women from granting the Lebanese nationality to their children because we’re afraid for the “demographic balance”. We prevent Palestinian refugees from leading dignified lives because of the “demographic balance”. We have artificial politics and bureaucracy structures based on sects to preserve the “demographic balance”. We don’t have an official, scientific census of the Lebanese population because -you guessed it- we’re afraid that the results might upset the demographic balance.
But you have to know that the tyranny of the demographic balance can conquer politics, culture and even sports. But it cannot touch the free market. Adults will always find ways to sell their property to a willing buyer, even if they had to go to Cyprus to do it.
–
Note: Posts with titles starting with an ❊ (asterisk) are my opinion and article posts. I used this system to separate long posts from quick links and comments.

The Butros Harb law doesn’t need to be stopped. The law was never intended to be voted in the first place. It was only intended to strengthen the sectarian credentials of the deputy who proposed it.
March 14 is a farce….this is their vision for the modern state….
15 years is not that much.
You know, the US government stopped home foreclosures for some time, until the economy stabilized. (I think it is still in effect). Let’s face it, the majority of the Lebanese society is still immature, and maybe they need some stupid laws to elevate them to a less stupid level. Maybe Harb is on to something here. He is part of this mentality, and maybe he sees something we don’t.
As we say in Lebanon: Give your bread to the baker.
Welcome back online to beirutspring, once again.
Thanks Shiwahad. You and anon make a good point on the political posturing of Harb.
I fully support this law, and I hope it passes (it never will though). Some of the advantages :
- Make the illegal money coming from some places useless (Iran, drugs, etc…)
- Put a halt to increase of real estate
- Putting a stop to the active change of demographics of some regions
Ideally, the law would be changed to create a special committee to review every “sensitive real estate transaction. This committee would be composed of elected leaders from the civil society + representatives of religious authorities.