Scandal: In Lebanon, Facebook Comments Can Land You In Jail



Plain Talking

A case involving four Lebanese university students being jailed for “insulting” a woman on Facebook shows just how backward our justice system can be.

Last year in the U.S, a girl by the name of Megan Meier was found dead in her room. She had hanged herself.

Megan wasn’t particularly attractive and she had troubles with her parents. Fortunately, she found solace at Myspace with a boy who regularly complimented her and told her how wonderful she looked. The couple would chat everyday, and Megan got out of her depressive mood.

A few weeks later, the boy suddenly turned on her and used a barrage of hurtful language:  I wonder why anyone would want be your friend! He told her. The troubled girl ended up killing herself.

Later it was found out that the “boy” never existed. He was a fictional Myspace character designed by the Meiers’ next-door neighbors specifically to cause them harm (although they didn’t mean to have the girl kill herself)

Everyone in the neighborhood knew about this, but it took national TV coverage and intense pressure for legal action to finally take place. The reason? Internet privacy rights that many Americans take for granted.

Why am I bringing this up?

Just to contrast it with the silly Lebanese legal system that jailed 4 university students simply because they had gossiped on Facebook about one woman’s singing.

How backward do you have to be to do that? The act wasn’t very nice, but come on, hasn’t each one of you at some point made fun of someone else on Facebook?

Sometimes, Lebanese officials just need to get a life.

Entries (RSS)Do you like this post? Would you like to be always updated with new posts on this website? If so, please subscribe to this blog's RSS feed? (tell me more)


 

Discussion

Comments are disallowed for this post.


  1.  

    they just have to join Hatebook :p

    would be alright to make such comments there?

    Posted by frenchy | January 17, 2008, 12:51 pm

  2.  

    cant agree with you on that
    lebanese people must learn about their real rights. insulting a woman in a matter related to her feminity is sexual offense, something that seems to be acceptable in lebanese masculine society, but its god damn illegal in human rights respecting countries.

    Posted by Roch | January 18, 2008, 7:20 pm

  3.  

    How come all of the previous comments were deleted?

    Posted by Ali | January 18, 2008, 10:25 pm

  4.  

    Ali, they weren’t deleted. In fact, they were amazing! I just had a problem where I think my Database reset to a day back and took away the latest post (Frangieh) and the last 5 comments..sorry

    Posted by Mustapha | January 19, 2008, 8:25 am

  5.  

    insulting a woman in a matter related to her feminity is sexual offense, something that seems to be acceptable in lebanese masculine society, but its god damn illegal in human rights respecting countries.

    Uhm what universe is this in?

    Let me say, Yoko Ono is a terrible singer. I’ll wait here for the cops.

    Posted by Joshua Scholar | January 19, 2008, 9:41 am

  6.  

    That’s why I blog anonymously (and from a foreign country).

    That’s why Lebanon is a backward country slipping further back.

    Waiting for the day when treason, blowing up MPs, and beating your friends in a Faraya chalet become as UNACCEPTABLE as badmouthing some singing nincompoop.

    tata

    Posted by Joseywales | January 19, 2008, 2:49 pm

  7.  

    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sexual_harassment

    its in this universe, but you seem to be unemployed and dont get frequent sexual harassment memos.

    I dont care about the singer, I dont even know who she is. And yes its unacceptable that people get killed while other party. Or that politician betray lebanon but still are considered as leaders.

    But i stoped wondering why are things going so badly when I figured out that its not just related to politics but to civic manners.

    havent you seen the cheering people when they hear aoun call other politicians animals? they applaude him just on that word!!!!

    Posted by Roch | January 19, 2008, 6:57 pm

  8.  

    [...] [link] [via] [...]

    Posted by And Far Away » ??? ?????? ????? | January 20, 2008, 8:28 am

Hello, my name is Mustapha and I blog in The Beirut Spring about Lebanese society and politics. I started in February 2005 after the killing of P.M. Rafik Hariri.

Subscribe
Subscribers so far:

Latest Posts

“Hi Kifak Ca Va” Pride
March 1, By Mustapha
The Future of February 14’s Celebrations
February 15, By Mustapha
Test Post – Please Ignore
February 14, By Mustapha
In God We Don’t Trust
November 16, By Mustapha

Lebanese Bloggers

Middle Eastern Bloggers

Blog Featured In


 

Today In Lebanon (NOW)

Naharnet RSS Feed

  • Two Israeli Tanks Cross Fence at Wazzani Point but Not Blue Line
  • Special Tribunal for Lebanon Appoints New Chief of Investigations
  • Man Arrested in North Lebanon for Sister's 'Honor Killing'
  • EU Official in Beirut to Discuss Prospects for Peace
  • Judiciary Calls for Death Penalty against Abu Madi's Suspected Killer
  • Police Arrest 44 in Night Raids
  • Maqdah Rejects Abbas' Offer to Move Out of Lebanon
  • Jumblat Surprised at Different Damascus Visit Dates Circulated by Media
  • Berri Says Possible Participation in Libya's Arab Summit Challenges Judicial Verdicts Against Gadhafi
  • Murr: No Army Protection for Tribunal
  • State Department: Torture and Extralegal Intimidation of Journalists
  • Suleiman Will Not Attend Arab Summit in Libya
  • Syria: Border Demarcation Bilateral Issue, No Palestinian Bases on Border with Lebanon
  • U.S.-Syrian Dialogue: Senate to Hear Ford's Testimony, Feltman and Shapiro in Damascus this Month
  • Berri Describes as 'Very Dangerous' the Alleged Signing of Saniora Government of Security Agreement with U.S. Embassy
  • Biden Says U.S. to Keep on Supporting Lebanon Institutions, 1701 Implementation to Disarm Hizbullah
  • Suleiman: Israel's Settlement Expansion Plan Makes Peace Futile
  • Lebanese Tycoon, Choueiri, Buried in Hometown
  • Russian Ambassador: Time for Lebanese to Take Reins of Government
  • Parliament Not Eager to Adopt Proportional Representation Elections
  • New Appointments in Fatah Leadership, Maqdah Excluded
  • Ex-Lebanese Policeman Files Lawsuit against 4 Syrian Officers
  • Cabinet Forms Committee Tasked with Submitting Ideas on Appointments Mechanism
  • Syria Turns Blind Eye on Trials in Absentia for Lebanese Officials
  • Hariri to Visit Damascus for a Second Time in as Many Months
  • Gemayel Fears Lebanon May Become 'Lab for Israeli, Iranian Weapons'
  • Qassem Says Hizbullah Has Succeeded through Armed Resistance but Doesn't Oppose Diplomacy
  • Berri Meets Families of Plane Crash Victims, Promises Financial Aid
  • Soaid after March 14 Meeting: All Lebanese Responsible for Protecting Lebanon, Not Only Certain Group
  • Arslan Visits Gemayel in Bikfaya
  • Naharnet Exclusive: Guy Says 'No Imminent War on Lebanon, We Expect More from Syria'
  • Administrative Appointments High on Cabinet Agendas
  • Barak: Israel Not Looking for Confrontation but Lebanon Responsible for Any Attack
  • Israel Calls Off Maneuvers Near Lebanon, Syria after U.S. Pressure
  • Jumblat Says he Left Dialogue Session because of Hunger and Sleep
  • March 8-14 Differences Shackle Progress on Defense Strategy Talks
  • Asarta Says Tripartite Meeting Essential Coordination Mechanism
  • Aoun: We Fought a War with Israel as Syria Intervened to Aid Us, But We Haven't Joined Any Axis
  • Businessman Antoine Choueiri Dies after Long Battle with Illness
  • Sayyed: Mirza Committed Flagrant Violation of Judicial Deal with Syria
  • 3.8 Magnitude Earthquake Strikes off Sidon
  • Jumblat Favors Gradual Solution to Resistance Issue
  • Army Arrests Killers of 70-Year-Old
  • Hariri, March 14: Defense Strategy Only Item for Discussion
  • National Dialogue Adjourned Barely 2 Hours after it Convened
  • Lebanese Judiciary Dismisses 'Improperly Issued' Syrian Summons
  • Qassem Says Dialogue Won't Discuss 'Weapons' as They are Defense Strategy 'Outcome, Not Source'
  • Phalange Party Hopes Dialogue Would Lead to 'One Vision for Future of Security, Stability, Independence'
  • Jumblat Urges Media to Ensure Accuracy before Publishing Syria Visit News
  • Yalibnan RSS Feed

    Latest Lebanese News

    RSS Subscribers

    Categories

    • No categories