March 8’s Aoun Problem



Lebanese politics

Sleimen Franjieh, head of the Marada gives an insight of the kind of rut the opposition is in.


This is the size of the hole you’ll fall into

Albalad, citing knowledgeable sources, reported today that Franjieh advised Nabih Berri not to accept a compromise candidate or the opposition will lose Aoun and what he termed “Christian political cover.”

Franjieh, going against the declared goal of both sides to reach an “understanding” (taswia) said that it’s better to have March 14 hold a half+1 parliamentary session and let them chose their own President, because that would ‘disband’ March 14. Whereas a compromise would undo the opposition itself.

The same sources told albalad that “Hezbollah can’t get into a compromise because they gave Aoun guarantees for which they got paid in advance” (MOU, July War, Riots)

Knowing Albalad’s sympathy with Aoun, the sources might as well be part of the FPM, indirectly threatening their allies.

Entries (RSS)Do you like this post? Would you like to be always updated with new posts on this website? If so, please subscribe to this blog's RSS feed? (tell me more)


 

Discussion

Comments are disallowed for this post.


  1.  

    I completely agree with this analysis.

    If we should have learned anything about Michel Aoun in the last two years is that the Presidency is his number one priority. His immense desire and love for power is illustrated in both the fact that he claims to represent the whole Christian community and that HE and only HE is entitled to the Presidency. Also that in his aspiration to become President he was even willing to break away from the original FPM political program and pre-summer 2005 ideals in his bid to become President.

    This is why today the opposition has a predicament. Why should Aoun continue to support them and risk a further decline in his political support base among the Christians, predominantly among the sect he claims to represent, if his payment for the sacrifice he is making is going to be met. I think its actually a predicament for Michel Aoun as well. Just like Michael Young said in one of his articles, Aoun can potentially be king-maker, but will never be king.

    I believe Michel Aoun’s greatest move would be to reassess his long-term political objectives, and the future of the country if a consensus candidate was elected. I think he’ll find that in the long-run if he is seen as the king-maker that made a March 14 candidate President king, then he might just be hailed as a liberator. He would get back all the support he lost in the last two years, and he would definitely have a hand in picking more than half the christian ministers in cabinet.

    But in Lebanon an outcome like this is extremely far fetched. The status quo defined by the slow decay of the country will prevail. Choosing an indecisive President with no real views on anything will likely be the outcome. And as usual instead of going one way or the other with policy, political and economic agenda and reform etc. we will go nowhere just to keep everyone at a safe and equal dissatisfaction from the status quo.

    Who do you think benefits from that kind of outcome and status quo?

    Posted by m | August 17, 2007, 11:48 am

  2.  

    m said: “If we should have learned anything about Michel Aoun in the last two years is that the Presidency is his number one priority.”

    Dear m, Presidency is Aoun’s only priority!!! This guy is so narrow minded that he does not see anything else other than the Presidential Palace!!!

    Posted by GK | August 17, 2007, 12:55 pm

  3.  

    honestly did you see how the guy couldnt keep his head striaght while he was speaking with Marcel Ghanem on Kalam al nas, also watch the way he was sitting is that a possible future president, he was sitting like a gangster one hand in his pocket and while the he was on television, he is digusting.

    Posted by fadi | August 17, 2007, 1:39 pm

  4.  

    Actually Mustapha I would desribe Nasrallah as telling everyone….that THIS is how big my anus is…and michy can fit straight through. Yalla!

    Ayesh Lubnan!

    Posted by Shunkleash | August 17, 2007, 1:58 pm

  5.  

    “”I believe Michel Aoun’s greatest move would be to reassess his long-term political objectives, and the future of the country if a consensus candidate was elected.”"

    First – one would have to believe that Aoun has “long term objectives” — his objectives have always been for him and at his age, they can be nothing but short term.
    The FPM movement was and is just a vehicle for his goal of the chair.

    One of the interesting things I’ve noticed is that the “warlord” Geagea fully understands about being a “Kingmaker”. Aoun had many chances to be a “hero” and he let them all go .. It is doubtful he will change now.
    It was clear on Jan 23 that this “opposition” was a failure and he lost his biggest chance right then. He could have pulled out and he might even have been able to talk his way into the chair with enough mea culpas.

    Posted by Ace | August 17, 2007, 2:33 pm

  6.  

    After reading all the previous comments, I have a question: if Aoun is so obviously only after one goal, why is he still so popular and why does he still have a large party following? I have not seen members of his party leave. And he still commands a large following with the population. Is there a reason for that?

    Posted by leo | August 17, 2007, 7:53 pm

  7.  

    Paul Fares for president!

    Posted by Leb Christian | August 17, 2007, 8:52 pm

  8.  

    leo, many members of his party left. My father being one of them. They’d like you to think that they are stronger then ever. But the simple fact is that Aoun’s “MOU” with Hezballah did not go well with his base.

    Posted by Leb Christian | August 17, 2007, 9:01 pm

  9.  

    leo,

    I agree. It does appear strange. And when I first started following Lebanese politics I was also flabbergasted at why leaders could change positions, have contrary positions, dismiss facts etc. and still not lose popular support.

    The problem is that you are framing things based on the logic of Western politics and this is Lebanon. So.

    Here is an easy to use chart. This the way the average brain in Lebanon processes new information.

    1- The Zaame (leader) is always right
    2- Conspiracy theories make all inconsistencies consistent
    3- Facts and logic

    If you note, level 3 is never reached because there is always a Zaame statement or conspiracy theory out there that will nullify it.

    I hope this helped :-)

    Posted by Ramzi S | August 17, 2007, 9:46 pm

  10.  

    Thanks for the reply.
    I still finf it hard to believe.

    Posted by leo | August 17, 2007, 11:03 pm

  11.  

    Ramzi, you forgot an important rule!

    2.5 – It must be somebody else fault.

    Posted by my-za'im-is-the-best | August 18, 2007, 2:31 am

  12.  

    [...] • I’ve been writing about Aoun’s “right” for the presidency for some time. In September 2005, I argued that since the Shiaas chose Amal for the Speaker’s position (instead of the more popular Hezbollah), it is unfair to say that the most popular politician in a sect is entitled to the highest post • In October 2006, I highlighted a comment which gives an alternative theory on why Aoun is entitled to the presidency • Last March, I wrote about the problems the opposition are having with Aoun. [...]

    Posted by Lebanon Moving Towards “Vacuum Management” | The Beirut Spring, a Lebanese Blog | November 22, 2007, 5:52 pm
  13. Posted by rybrn | February 19, 2008, 2:52 pm

Hello, my name is Mustapha and I blog in The Beirut Spring about Lebanese society and politics. I started in February 2005 after the killing of P.M. Rafik Hariri.

Subscribe
Subscribers so far:

Latest Posts

“Hi Kifak Ca Va” Pride
March 1, By Mustapha
The Future of February 14’s Celebrations
February 15, By Mustapha
Test Post – Please Ignore
February 14, By Mustapha
In God We Don’t Trust
November 16, By Mustapha

Lebanese Bloggers

Middle Eastern Bloggers

Blog Featured In


 

Today In Lebanon (NOW)

Naharnet RSS Feed

  • Hariri Says Campaign Against Suleiman 'Unacceptable'
  • Qassem: Nobody in Lebanon Has the Right to Invent a New Decision Named 'Defeat and Surrender Decision'
  • Aoun: I Don't Want to Hear Anyone Talking about the Resistance Anymore, March 14 Has Fallen to Pieces
  • Muallem Describes as 'Accurate' Hizbullah Statement on Jumblat Visit to Syria
  • Court Approves Retrial of Rafeh after He was Sentenced to Death
  • Lebanese University Teachers Set to Strike on Monday
  • Lebanese Citizen Arrested for Allegedly Spying for Israel
  • Arabs Step Up Mediation in Effort to Quell Lebanon-Libya Crisis
  • Baroud: Parliament has Right to Approve, Amend or Reject Municipal Election Law
  • Syria Extends Reconciliatory Hand to Jumblat after Nasrallah Played Key Mediation Role
  • Nasrallah Informs Jumblat That Assad is Ready to Meet Him Soon
  • Judge Issues Arrest Warrants Against 4 of Sehnaoui's Bodyguards
  • Hariri after Meeting Merkel: Peace Process Not Advancing Because of Extremists
  • Lebanese Embassy in Damascus Turns Down Libya's Invitation to Arab Summit
  • Libya Hands Over Summit Invitation to Lebanese Ambassador in Syria
  • New Druze Group Mocks Jumblat: Regaining Rationalism is a Blessing!
  • Jumblat: I Have a Lot to Tell Assad When I Meet Him
  • Aoun: Internal Stability Not Meant to Stifle Political Speech
  • Hariri from Germany: We Cannot Protect Lebanon if Division and Mistrust Continue
  • No Official Syrian Response to Jumblat's Remarks, Al-Watan: Jumblat Didn't Apologize
  • Cassese: Justice is Coming … Killers to Be Identified
  • Aoun: We Are the Basis of March 14
  • March 14 Vows Independence Uprising Will Continue Until It Reaches Objectives, Suggests 7-Point Plan
  • Bazzi to Amr Moussa: No Mediation Requested for Libya Arab Summit
  • 2 French Peacekeepers Killed, 3 Injured in Personnel Carrier Accident
  • Geagea: Weapons Outside State Control Sign of Abnormality
  • March 14 to Unveil Vision on Lebanon's Protection
  • Jumblat Admits Offending Assad, Not Sure Syrian President Could Tolerate Him
  • Hariri: Any Regional War Direct Result of International Community Inaction
  • Lebanese-Syrian Quarrel after Security Council Session
  • Williams Hopes Lebanese Political Factions Would Agree on National Dialogue Timeframe
  • Two Israeli Tanks Cross Fence at Wazzani Point but Not Blue Line
  • Special Tribunal for Lebanon Appoints New Chief of Investigations
  • Man Arrested in North Lebanon for Sister's 'Honor Killing'
  • EU Official in Beirut to Discuss Prospects for Peace
  • Berri Says Possible Participation in Libya's Arab Summit Challenges Judicial Verdicts Against Gadhafi
  • Suleiman Will Not Attend Arab Summit in Libya
  • Syria: Border Demarcation Bilateral Issue, No Palestinian Bases on Border with Lebanon
  • U.S.-Syrian Dialogue: Senate to Hear Ford's Testimony, Feltman and Shapiro in Damascus this Month
  • Yalibnan RSS Feed

    Latest Lebanese News

    RSS Subscribers

    Categories

    • No categories