An Unwise Move



Uncategorized


The Patriarch’?s latest decision to protect President Lahhoud is not only morally indefensible, it’?s also a strategic mistake that will reduce the church’?s influence.


When the Council Of Bishops announced a few days ago that the Presidency’?s fate should be left to constitutional channels, most Lebanese understood the message: The Patriarch is against dethroning President Lahhoud by force.

The Patriarch’?s logic, on the surface of it, is a sensible one: As a guarantor of the role and influence of the Christians in Lebanon, it would be irresponsible for him to allow for a precedent where the most senior Christian in the land (the President), is kicked out of office and humiliated.

But as Sarkis Naoum, one of Annahar’s most senior and most objective journalists, argued a few days back, the Patriarch is in fact unwittingly reducing the influence of the Christians in the long run.

Naoum noted that Lahhoud’?s international and local isolation has “?let the grass grow on the road to Baabda Palace”?. Most international diplomats and envoys are getting used to visiting Mr. Seniora and ignoring President Lahhoud. If Lahhoud stays as President, the argument goes, people will get used to that state of affairs and the Presidency will soon become a de-facto powerless institution.

In other words, The Patriarch might think he’?s giving President Lahhoud some strength, but in reality, Bkirki is the one weakned by the current Baabda resident. People who previously did not dare criticize the Patriarch are starting to voice (although politely) their frustration. Sarkis Naoum went as far yesterday as saying that the patriarch was played by President Lahhoud.

If Patriarch Sfeir doesn’?t undo his latest move, the coming winds of change are going to take Bkirki’?s prestige and influence with them.

Entries (RSS)Do you like this post? Would you like to be always updated with new posts on this website? If so, please subscribe to this blog's RSS feed? (tell me more)


 

Discussion

Comments are disallowed for this post.


  1.  

    Totally agree Steve,

    Just posted and linked to your post on this issue. Check out what Aoun said today.

    http://lebanonesque.blogspot.com/

    Posted by JoseyWales | November 5, 2005, 1:48 pm

  2.  

    Dude,

    No offense, but who are you exactly to lecture pompously on “the Patriarch’s latest decision” or the “fledging influence of the Church”??

    Personally I’m no fan of the wobbly Bishop of Albuquerque for he’s often been far too soft on faux sheikh Saad-uldînne, the Wahhabi-friendly Mufti of the Republic and other subservient Saudi/Neocon stooges who happen to hate both Christianity and Arabism…

    BUT I think H.E. Cardinal Nasrallah Sfeir actually did precisely what he had to do when he backed President Lahoud against the vile ad-hominem attacks and other overtly anti-Christian slurs coming from Riyadh and TeX-Aviv!

    Posted by Dr Victorino de la Vega | November 5, 2005, 3:22 pm

  3.  

    Perhaps this may sound very simplistic, indicating my political naivety. But what if the Patriarch and his crew are responding to the intransigence of Jumblat specifically, not to mention the countless other Syrian stooges who were criticizing Bkerki back when it was calling for the Syrians to leave, before it was fashionable to do so!

    Lahoud must go. I agree with that, but why should it fall on Bkerki to undo the dirty deed committed by parliament? Some of the people calling for his departure, had a historic opportunity to vote against extending his term, instead they acquiesced and their cowardice prevailed (Noted, Jumblat’s posse didn’t vote).

    Finally, I hope to see a day when Bkerki and all other religious institutions in Lebanon leave politics to politicians.

    Boutros

    Posted by Anonymous | November 5, 2005, 3:25 pm

  4.  

    I completely agree. They should have secured a deal with the FM instead of protecting a guy like Lahoud. It is a mistake. The patriarch’s parochial behaviour is disappointing.

    Posted by Vox Populi - Agent Provocateur | November 5, 2005, 8:03 pm

  5.  

    They didn’t even get substantial concession from Lahoud. It’s really amazing, especially when you know that the presidential elections are to be held in two years. The Christians will have nothing to negotiate by then. This is really a short-sighted policy.

    Posted by Vox Populi - Agent Provocateur | November 5, 2005, 8:06 pm

  6.  

    Hopefully, by the end of President Lahoud’s last term, this Wahhabi-controlled puppet-Parliament will have been dissolved and faux sheikh Saad-uldînne jailed, or even better guillotined for all the “centre ville” billions he has embezzled!

    Lebanon’s MP’s and other courageous Harirista resistants of the eleventh hour got their current jobs under the auspices of an illegal electoral law spiced with a heavy dose of Gerrymander that was cooked in the dirty political kitchens of Saudistan and backed at gun point by the Syrian regime- recall: the moustached martyr millionaire and Gen. Ghazi Canaan were best pals in the merry halcyon days of faux sheikh Rafiq and his collaborationist friends…

    Caramba!
    Viva la Revolución
    Viva el General Aoun
    Viva el General Alcázar
    Viva el Coronel Chávez
    Y el Capitán Tintín

    ;-)

    Posted by Dr Victorino de la Vega | November 5, 2005, 10:07 pm

Hello, my name is Mustapha and I blog in The Beirut Spring about Lebanese society and politics. I started in February 2005 after the killing of P.M. Rafik Hariri.

Subscribe
Subscribers so far:

Latest Posts

“Hi Kifak Ca Va” Pride
March 1, By Mustapha
The Future of February 14’s Celebrations
February 15, By Mustapha
Test Post – Please Ignore
February 14, By Mustapha
In God We Don’t Trust
November 16, By Mustapha

Lebanese Bloggers

Middle Eastern Bloggers

Blog Featured In


 

Today In Lebanon (NOW)

Naharnet RSS Feed

  • Suleiman: Israel's Settlement Expansion Plan Makes Peace Futile
  • Lebanese Tycoon, Choueiri, Buried in Hometown
  • Russian Ambassador: Time for Lebanese to Take Reins of Government
  • Parliament Not Eager to Adopt Proportional Representation Elections
  • New Appointments in Fatah Leadership, Maqdah Excluded
  • Ex-Lebanese Policeman Files Lawsuit against 4 Syrian Officers
  • Syria Turns Blind Eye on Trials in Absentia for Lebanese Officials
  • Cabinet Considering Mechanism for Appointments
  • Hariri to Visit Damascus for a Second Time in as Many Months
  • Gemayel Fears Lebanon May Become 'Lab for Israeli, Iranian Weapons'
  • Qassem Says Hizbullah Has Succeeded through Armed Resistance but Doesn't Oppose Diplomacy
  • Berri Meets Families of Plane Crash Victims, Promises Financial Aid
  • Soaid after March 14 Meeting: All Lebanese Responsible for Protecting Lebanon, Not Only Certain Group
  • Arslan Visits Gemayel in Bikfaya
  • Naharnet Exclusive: Guy Says 'No Imminent War on Lebanon, We Expect More from Syria'
  • Administrative Appointments High on Cabinet Agendas
  • Barak: Israel Not Looking for Confrontation but Lebanon Responsible for Any Attack
  • Israel Calls Off Maneuvers Near Lebanon, Syria after U.S. Pressure
  • Jumblat Says he Left Dialogue Session because of Hunger and Sleep
  • March 8-14 Differences Shackle Progress on Defense Strategy Talks
  • Asarta Says Tripartite Meeting Essential Coordination Mechanism
  • Aoun: We Fought a War with Israel as Syria Intervened to Aid Us, But We Haven't Joined Any Axis
  • Businessman Antoine Choueiri Dies after Long Battle with Illness
  • Sayyed: Mirza Committed Flagrant Violation of Judicial Deal with Syria
  • 3.8 Magnitude Earthquake Strikes off Sidon
  • Jumblat Favors Gradual Solution to Resistance Issue
  • Army Arrests Killers of 70-Year-Old
  • Hariri, March 14: Defense Strategy Only Item for Discussion
  • National Dialogue Adjourned Barely 2 Hours after it Convened
  • Lebanese Judiciary Dismisses 'Improperly Issued' Syrian Summons
  • Qassem Says Dialogue Won't Discuss 'Weapons' as They are Defense Strategy 'Outcome, Not Source'
  • Phalange Party Hopes Dialogue Would Lead to 'One Vision for Future of Security, Stability, Independence'
  • Jumblat Urges Media to Ensure Accuracy before Publishing Syria Visit News
  • Yalibnan RSS Feed

    Latest Lebanese News

    RSS Subscribers

    Categories

    • No categories