Geagea Should Walk The Talk



Uncategorized


The LF is not doing enough to change its image.


When the victorious Samir Geagea made that public speech in the Airport when he was released from prison, people were listening to a man speaking like a national leader. It was obvious that Mr. Geagea had made his strategic decision to move the party he leads to more moderate waters. Yesterday, the LF students, in their First Annual Conference, celebrated a “new Lebanon”, one where people are “free to express their opinions”. Mr. Ahmad Fatfat, a Sunni Haririst, was a star speaker of the show.

Yet doubts still remain about how much the LF is actually doing to improve its image. Take the issue of the crucifix shaped as a dagger (a symbol perceived by many to be offensive). In his first interview since he was released from prison Mr. Geagea

‘expressed his surprise and discontent at his party’s adoption of the “dagger cross”. Commenting on the crucifix ending in a dagger that has become synonymous with the Lebanese Forces party, Geagea said: “This is not our motto. Some of the youths who decided to bear it did so after the LF was disbanded. When I was released I was surprised to hear about the dagger-cross.”‘

But if you look at the picture that his followers have unwittingly posted on his website to celebrate his birthday (shown above), it is clear that Mr. Geagea is cutting a cake that has the very symbol he pretended he didn’t know about.

But forget about the past, let’s talk about the future:

‘Geagea explained he has called upon party members not to display the dagger-cross, adding that “an internal memorandum has been issued on that matter.”‘

If that is the case, then why is the symbol still prominently placed on the LF’s website?

I trust That Mr. Geagea’s motives are good. I even understand why he would politically need some time to move his base with him. But in his interview he seemed willing to take the first symbolic step; so please Mr. Geagea, start with your official website.

**Erratum**
It was brought to my attention that http://www.lebaneseforces.com is NOT the LF’s official website. Their official website is http://www.lebanese-forces.com.
Thanks Khaled and Anonymous

Entries (RSS)Do you like this post? Would you like to be always updated with new posts on this website? If so, please subscribe to this blog's RSS feed? (tell me more)


 

Discussion

No comments for “Geagea Should Walk The Talk”

  1. Mustapha
    I agree with you that the statement he made about the cross-dagger is false ,maybe he forgot:-)

    but to be fair with LF, they have released a statement about the site you mentioned, it looks like it was hi-jacked by some one…. here is the statement of LF:

    القوات اللبنانية تنظم مواقعها على الانترنت 19/10/2005 07:20:28 م

    اصدرت دائرة الاعلام والتوجيه في القوات اللبنانية في الخارج بيانا جاء فيه:

    “ان الدائرة واستنادا الى القرارات والتوجيهات السياسية العامة للقوات اللبنانية, وحرصا على مصلحة القوات اللبنانية وصورتها امام الرأي العام, وفي اطار اعادة ضبط وتنظيم المواقع العامة باسم القوات اللبنانية على الانترنت تقرر ما يلي:

    1- تشكل لجنة اعلام لفترة موقتة تعمل باشراف مسؤول الاعلام والتوجيه تعنى بمواقع القوات العاملة على الانترنت من الرفاق التالية اسماؤهم: ادمون الشدياق, ايلي سمعان, تريز عساف, جان خوري, جوزيف العلم, جورج نصر, زاهي هليط, عادل سليمان, نقولا شحود ووسام نصر.

    2- يعتمد موقع الانترنت التالي موقعا رسميا وحيدا للقوات اللبنانية, معبرا عن توجهاتها وخطها السياسي http://www.lebanese-forces.com

    3- يعتمد http://www.lebforces.org/forum LF Official Forumموقعا رسميا للمناقشات ولتبادل الآراء.

    4- تعتمد شهادتنا كنشرة توجيهية داخلية تصدر عن امانة الاعلام والتوجيه في القوات اللبنانية http://www.chahadatouna.com

    5- ينتهي العمل بغرف المناقشة كافة “البالتولك” القائمة حاليا, ويستعاض عنها بغرفة بالتولك واحدة باسم “القوات اللبنانية” Lebanese Forces Paltalk Room تعمل باشراف دائرة الاعلام والتوجيه, تضم جميع الراغبين من الرفاق القواتيين والاصدقاء.

    6- تعتبر باقي المواقع والغرف العاملة باسم القوات اللبنانية والتي تطلق على نفسها صفة رسمية او غير رسمية مواقع خاصة غير تابعة للقوات اللبنانية, تعرض المسؤولين عنها في حال الاستمرار للملاحقات القانونية كونها منتحلة صفة.

    7- استكمالا لتوحيد الشكل الذي تطل من خلاله القوات اللبنانية على العالم, وبناء على توجيهات قيادة القوات اللبنانية, يعتمد ابتداء من تاريخه, الى جانب العلم اللبناني, شعار القوات اللبنانية (الدائرة الحمراء التي تتوسطها الارزة على الاعلام واليافطات والمطبوعات كافة في الاجتماعات والمؤتمرات والمناسبات والتجمعات الشعبية والسياسية كافة, دون غيره من الشعارات.

    يضاف الى جانب العلم اللبناني وعلم القوات اللبنانية علم البلد الذي يستضيف هذه المناسبات في حال حصولها خارج لبنان.

    8- يطلب من جميع الرفاق التعاون في سبيل وضع هذه المذكرة موضع التنفيذ.

    Posted by khaled | October 27, 2005, 3:16 pm
  2. Mustapha,

    Your post contains a lot of inconsistencies. I have no great admiration for the man’s past but for the sake of posterity let me make a couple of comments:

    - Firstly he did not “found” the party.
    - The website you have linked to is not the official party website; it doesn’t even claim to be the official website. This is the official party website (http://www.forces-libanaises.com/). Not to be confused with another supposedly “official party website” (http://www.lebanese-forces.org/). Serious efforts are underway to have one common and official party website. But for now this is the one associated with Geagea and as you can see no dagger cross.
    - To say that Geagea “pretended he didn’t know about” the cross is grossly misleading. How can you deduce that from the statement he gave? The statement was aimed at the prevailing usage of the cross as the motto and not at its existence within the party.

    Man, if this symbol irks you then you must have seeeerious issues with the flag of Hezbollah.

    Posted by Anonymous | October 27, 2005, 3:26 pm
  3. I really believe that the Hakim is a changed man. But he has to be careful and walk a fine line, if he shows that he is too much pro FM and their allies, he might lose much support among the christians, just like Fares Said and Nassib Lahoud, and GMA can then claim most of the Hakim supporters. Unfortunatly the confessionalism disease is still existing in Lebanon despite the high cost that Lebanese has paid because of it in the last 30 years. I just hope that the deputy Georges Adwan is not speaking in the LF name, because he seems to me that he is more and more speaking like an Aounist than an LF.

    Posted by Anonymous | October 27, 2005, 4:13 pm
  4. A thug is a thug is a thug is a thug.

    But what matters is that we all hate Lahoud.

    FGA

    Posted by Anonymous | October 27, 2005, 4:30 pm
  5. The ‘dagger’ cross wasn’t initially indented to be a dagger, even if most people (Christians and Muslim) see it this way nowadays. If you look closely at the cross, you’ll notice that it’s not really designed to be a dagger. This cross appeared in a special context, at a time when the presence of the Christians in Lebanon was threatened and it was rumoured that Kissinger was in favour of relocating the Christians abroad. The cross was designed so that it could be pushed in Lebanon’s soil, symbolizing the fact that Christianity was rooted in Lebanon – hence Bashir Gemayel’s favourite expression : ‘wa nabka’, ‘we’ll stay’.

    I personally don’t wear a cross and don’t think that this important symbol should not be politicized. The original meaning of the cross was something positive, but it’s not the case anymore, because most people associate it with a dagger. I think that people should stop using this cross but that it will not happen because Middle Eastern Christians historically associate hiding or removing the cross to religious persecutions. I mentioned this subject with several LF militants and the answer was always the same, and it’s not related to stabbing Muslims. They always gave me the same reply: ‘ we are not ashamed of the cross and we will never be afraid to wear a cross in our own country’.

    Posted by Anonymous | October 27, 2005, 7:34 pm
  6. In the comment above, I meant:
    “I personally don’t wear a cross and think that this important symbol should not be politicized.”

    Posted by Anonymous | October 27, 2005, 7:35 pm
  7. Khaled and First Anonymous,
    Thanks for bringing to my attention the website’s issue.

    Anonymous (first), i will fix the founding of the party part. but I’m not convinced with what you said about the cross dagger. why would he cut a cake with that sole symbol on it if the symbol didn’t have any strong icnonological value? (like being a logo for instance)

    As for the Hizbullah Logo, you can say that again. You’re probably a new reader but i’ve mocked them twice before

    Posted by Mustapha | October 27, 2005, 8:02 pm
  8. The risk is that if Samir Geagea tries to shift the LF too much in a different direction, he will alienate the LF rank and file.
    Although most LFers look at Samir Geagea as a God like figure, and will follow him regardless for the most part, there are still limits to what he can and can’t do, without losing their support. For example, regarding the issue of the LF Cross, although he said that he doesn’t want it ot be associated with the LF anymore, the word on the street is that most LFers in the open want to follow their leader and the party line, however, in private, most don’t want to see the Cross taken away, and will still use it.

    If Samir Geagea can’t get rid of a symbol, how can people expect him to do much else?

    Posted by Anonymous | October 28, 2005, 3:41 am
  9. Mustapha,

    With reference to your comment at 8:02, I provide you with this link.

    http://www.lebaneseforces.com/lfcross.asp

    That aside, please check the new look of the official website.

    http://www.lebanese-forces.com/

    Things are going to quick, just give us some time, would you?

    Regards,

    Posted by Anonymous | October 28, 2005, 8:01 am
  10. The cross was the symbol of the Christian Resistance, and should not be confused with the Lebanese-Forces political party
    don’t get lost, if u search&read well u can see that the cross is “Salib al moukawama al Loubnaniya” and not “salib 7izb al kouwat al loubnaniya”
    c’mon guys, search well before criticizing!!!
    best regards…

    Posted by Anonymous | January 4, 2006, 3:27 pm

Post a comment

Hello, my name is Mustapha and I blog in The Beirut Spring about Lebanese society and politics. I started in February 2005 after the killing of P.M. Rafik Hariri.

Rss

Subscribe
 

Latest Posts

Israel Might Do Something…Anything
Israel Might Do Something…Anything
August 8, By Mustapha
The Beirut Spring Is Now A Family
The Beirut Spring Is Now A Family
August 7, By Mustapha
General Petraeus’ Visit To Lebanon. Protocol Or More?
General Petraeus’ Visit To Lebanon. Protocol Or More?
August 6, By Mustapha
Guest Writer: Why It Matters That Mika Is Not Lebanese
Guest Writer: Why It Matters That Mika Is Not Lebanese
August 4, By Mustapha

More From the Beirutspring network

Lebanese Bloggers

Middle Eastern Bloggers

RSS Subscribers

Blog Featured In